Skip to Content

15 Best Vintage Toys to Sell on Ebay for Profit

eBay is a platform where people sell different things, and of course, there are several things that are in high demand that an aspiring entrepreneur can sell on eBay. One such product is vintage toys. Anyone can sell vintage toys on eBay for profit because it is simple to do so.

Basically, selling on eBay involves creating a seller account, listing items with detailed descriptions and images, setting prices or allowing bidding, and selecting shipping options. Once a buyer purchases an item, the seller ships it, and eBay facilitates the transaction.

Sellers may choose auction-style or fixed-price listings, and fees are incurred based on the final sale price. Feedback from buyers contributes to the seller’s reputation on the platform, influencing future transactions.

If you are planning to sell vintage toys on eBay, and you wondering what types of vintage toys will sell fast, then you may want to continue reading this article.

Best Vintage Toys to Sell on eBay for Profit

  1. Vintage Transformers

If you are lucky to still have original transformers from the ’80s, you can sell them for a mouthwatering price that guarantees you a high profit.

You can actually sell any of your vintage transformers (Sealed: $1800 Opened: $222 Loose: $117). It should come as no surprise that the original toys are worth the most, some fetching prices for that of a used car.

These so-called “Generation One” or “Gen 1” or “G1” toys are highly sought after by collectors, and bidding wars happen on a regular basis.

  1. Classic LEGO Sets

Rare and complete LEGO sets, especially the ones from the ’70s and ’80s are in high demand now. One of the most obvious reasons why adults are rediscovering LEGO is the fun factor.

It’s exciting to open a box with hundreds or even thousands of pieces, and then use your skill and imagination to transform them into a spaceship or racing car.

The challenge of building also stimulates the brain and promotes creativity. If you can lay your hands on any of them, you can sell them for a premium because many toy lovers are currently looking for them.

  1. Nintendo Game Boy

Over the years, the demand for this vintage toy has not dwindled, and there are games and toy lovers out there who will be willing to pay a premium in order to get the Nintendo Game Boy in their collections.

The secret to Game Boy’s success was not driven by advanced graphics or processing power, but rather by simple and efficient design, head-to-head connectivity, and scores of intriguing games.

  1. Star Wars Figures

Since the first Star Wars movie, “A New Hope” came out on May 25, 1977, a lot of people have fallen in love with the movie and every symbol that represents the movie.

In general, the vintage Star Wars figures from when the films were first released tend to be worth the most money. These original figures are valuable for collectors, many of whom are drawn to them because of the nostalgia that they bring.

In essence, if you have any Original Star Wars action figures in good condition, you can rest assured that you will sell them at a premium price on eBay for good profits.

It might interest you to note that the most expensive Star Wars memorabilia ever sold is the famous R2-D2 droid. Auctioned in June 2017, the unique piece measures 43 inches in height.

  1. Barbie Dolls

Vintage Barbie dolls, especially those in original packaging can sell for as high as you want to sell it. Although Barbie is aimed at children, the inspiration for the toy is very adult-oriented.

Since 1959, Barbie’s purpose has been to inspire the limitless potential in every girl. As a matter of fact, in 1965, some 13 years before women were admitted to the astronaut corps at NASA, Mattel introduced an astronaut Barbie Doll.

  1. Hot Wheels Cars

Hot Wheels cars were designed to roll easily and at high speeds, which was a great innovation at the time. This is why Hot Wheels Cars are one of the best vintage toys you should consider selling on eBay for profit.

If you can lay your hands on rare and early editions of Hot Wheels cars, you will definitely sell them for premium prices and good profits. Value can depend on whether or not it’s in packaging and if there are any damages to the car.

  1. Fisher-Price Toys

In 1931, Herman Fisher, Irving Price & Helen Schelle embarked on a journey to change the toy industry. Their goal was to create playthings that inspire a child’s development (but are also fun).

One of Fisher-Price’s best-known lines is Little People toys, which include people and animal figures along with various play sets such as a house, farm, school, garage, and vehicles. The figures, which originally were wooden peg-style characters, are now molded of plastic and have detailed features.

  1. Cabbage Patch Kids

Cabbage Patch Kids is a line of cloth dolls with plastic heads first produced by Coleco Industries in 1982. In 1983, a Cabbage Patch Kids doll was a 16-inch doll, usually with a plastic head, a fabric body, and yarn hair (unless it was bald).

What made them so desirable, besides the fact that they were huggable, was both their supposed uniqueness and their “adoptability.”  

What makes a Cabbage Patch Kid valuable is its hair color including its style and length. Also, facial characteristics like nose shape, freckles, and eye color of the dolls will have an impact on value.

  1. Polly Pocket Sets

The best Polly Pocket toys by Mattel are great options for parents looking for alternatives to large dolls and doll houses that children can easily carry around when traveling.

Polly Pocket toy sets feature entertaining dolls and accessories and offer endless play possibilities to keep children entertained for hours.

Something about having a pocket-sized doll you could take anywhere you wanted was hugely appealing to young Millennials, and by the mid-’90s, Polly Pocket was one of the most popular toys for girls under 8 years old.

  1. Vintage Board Games

Collectible board games from the ’60s and ’70s no doubt are some of the best vintage toys you can sell on eBay for profit. Interestingly there are several board games from the ’60s and ’70s you can sell and make good profits.

All you need to do is sample people’s opinions of the types of board games from the ’60s and ’70s they would like to have in their collections of vintage games, and then go look for them.

Some of the board games from the ’60s and ’70s you should look out for are Dynamo Chess, Monopoly, Park and Shop, Feeley Meeley, Bucket of Fun, Bee Bop, Supercar (Milton Bradley), Hopalong Cassidy Game, Milton Bradley 1960 Men Into Space Game, and Green Ghost et al.

  1. Teddy Ruxpin

Most people who love teddy bears will want to do anything to have the original animatronic teddy bear from the ’80s in their collections of toys.

In essence, if you are looking for some of the best vintage toys to sell on eBay for profit, you should consider the Teddy Ruxpin (original animatronic teddy bear from the ’80s).

Teddy Ruxpin is an animatronic children’s toy in the form of a talking ‘Illiop’, a creature that looks like a bear. The toy’s mouth and eyes move while he reenacts stories played on an audio tape cassette deck built into its back.

  1. GI Joe Action Figures

The G.I. Joe: A Real American Hero toyline was introduced by Hasbro in 1982, and lasted until 1994, producing well over 250 vehicles. If you are lucky to still be in possession of one of GI Joe Action Figures, you can actually sell them for good profits

  1. My Little Pony

Early editions of My Little Pony toys are no doubt one of the best vintage toys you can sell on eBay for profit. The first incarnation of My Little Pony toy line by American toy company Hasbro began in 1982 as a successor of My Pretty Pony toys.

Trust me, vintage My Little Ponies can be worth money. Those from the original, first generation of ponies that were produced between 1982 and 1992 are usually worth the most. You’ll also want to consider whether the pony is rare or limited edition, which can add to its value.

  1. Atari Consoles and Games

The Atari VCS launched in 1977 with nine simple, low-resolution games in 2 KB cartridges. The system’s first killer app was the home conversion of Taito’s arcade game Space Invaders in 1980.

Although there are newer editions of Atari Consoles and Games, those that had the first release in the late seventies will not mind having them in their collections of toys if they come across one.

  1. Matchbox Cars

With most Matchbox cars, older vehicles tend to be more valuable than those produced in recent years. When a Matchbox car is produced in the first run of any specific model, it tends to be more valuable than those produced in subsequent years.

If you have any in your collections, it is advisable to do your research on your particular model to see what value it holds before listing it on eBay!

Note that some of the most valuable Matchbox cars are those that were produced in limited quantities or are considered to be rare. The value of a Matchbox car can also be affected by its condition.