Skip to Content

10 Best-Selling Coffee Shop Sandwich Menu ideas That Customers Love

Coffee Shop Sandwich Menu ideas

Starting a coffee shop is one thing but ensuring that it draws in the right crowd as well as becomes profitable is another thing altogether.

Aside from putting together a cozy atmosphere, brewing flavorful cups of coffee, and having freshly baked pastries, you must take your time to come up with the right menu since it is a crucial part of the experience, particularly the sandwiches.

Keep in mind that the right selection of sandwiches will complement the coffee, and ensure customers get a satisfying snack or meal option.

To ensure you can cater to the needs of customers, below are some of the best-selling sandwich ideas that every coffee shop needs to have on its menu.

Best-Selling Coffee Shop Sandwich Menu ideas

  1. Classic BLT (Bacon, Lettuce, and Tomato)

BLT remains a well-known perennial favorite owing to its simplicity and global appeal. To make this delicacy, you will need crispy bacon, fresh lettuce, and juicy tomatoes, sandwiched between toasted bread.

Keep in mind that the smoky flavor of the bacon in addition to the crunch of fresh vegetables aligns easily with a hot cup of coffee, and this makes it one of the best sellers in a good number of coffee shops.

Be sure to make available variations such as adding avocado or a fried egg to take it up a notch.

  1. Turkey and Swiss on Ciabatta

This is another top choice to consider because it is a classic choice for coffee shops that have intentions of catering to the lunch crowd. The turkey will bring the lean protein, while Swiss cheese brings the nutty richness.

This sandwich can be dressed up with ingredients such as fresh arugula, cranberry sauce, or Dijon mustard, ensuring that customers can relish a sophisticated but also very approachable flavor.

Also, note that the soft but chewy ciabatta bread adds that gourmet feel that coffee shop patrons can enjoy.

  1. Grilled Cheese with Tomato Soup

Grilled Cheese Menu ideas

You wouldn’t want to overlook this nostalgic favorite. Keep in mind that grilled cheese sandwich is loved by both young and old.

To ensure you draw the attention of customers, start with a simple concept and make it a top-seller by utilizing top-quality cheeses such as sharp cheddar, mozzarella, or Gouda, grilled to a perfect golden-brown crisp.

Consider serving them with a small cup of tomato soup to convert it from just a snack into a full meal.

  1. Caprese Sandwich

Caprese Panini Sandwich Menu ideas

The Caprese sandwich is light, refreshing, and full of flavor. It is made with fresh mozzarella, ripe tomatoes, as well as basil leaves, fully packed with balsamic glaze and olive oil, all tucked into a crusty baguette or focaccia.

You will indeed want to add this to your menu as it will grasp the attention of customers looking for a vegetarian option or something on the lighter side. It goes very well with both hot and iced coffee drinks.

  1. Ham and Brie Baguette

One of the first things to note about ham and brie sandwiches is that customers always enjoy its blend of savory and creamy flavors. Aside from being a top choice for foodies, it also appeals to casual diners.

Keep in mind that the richness of the brie aligns very well with the salty ham, and when served on a fresh, crusty baguette, it’s a mind-blowing delicacy.

However, if the plan is to make it stand out, then consider adding elements such as fig jam or caramelized onions.

Don’t forget that this sandwich is ideal for customers eager for something a little more refined, and it aligns very well with a strong coffee or espresso.

  1. Avocado and Egg Sandwich

When you consider the growing rise of avocado toast, you will see why the avocado and egg sandwich has become a hit for modern customers at any coffee shop menu.

Note that the creamy avocado aligns well with a runny or hard-boiled egg to give customers that satisfying and filling sandwich.

This option is highly customizable, you can choose to add extras such as bacon, spinach, or hot sauce.

Consider serving them on multi-grain or sourdough bread, since it is a renowned option for health-conscious customers or individuals who want a hearty breakfast option.

  1. Chicken Pesto Panini

This is one item that elevates your coffee shop menu and gives it that additional gourmet vibe.

Note that this is more or less a blend of grilled chicken, fresh pesto, mozzarella, and tomatoes, pressed between slices of ciabatta or focaccia bread.

Aside from being a well-known crowd-pleaser, it is imperative to note that this sandwich offers a combination of savory, herby, and cheesy flavors that can be enjoyed as a warm and filling meal. It is a good option for your shop menu since it is perfect for both lunch and dinner.

  1. Vegan Hummus and Veggie Wrap

This is the right option to consider if you plan to attract customers who love plant-based options.

When infused into a coffee shop menu, note that a vegan hummus and veggie wrap will make your shop a viable location for health-conscious customers.

Hummus is well renowned for being a creamy, protein-rich base, while fresh vegetables such as cucumbers, bell peppers, carrots, and spinach offer crunch and color.

You have to wrap it all up in whole-wheat tortilla to ensure you have a healthy, on-the-go option.

This sandwich goes very well with lighter coffee or tea options, attracting customers who are eager to enjoy a nutritious, meat-free choice.

  1. Tuna Salad Sandwich

Another popular choice that will tune up the experience you offer customers, tuna salad sandwiches are made with a creamy mixture of tuna, mayonnaise, celery, and spices. Your customers will indeed enjoy this satisfying and easy-to-prepare option.

If you want to elevate the experience, then you should look towards infusing a slice of cheddar cheese or using a croissant as the bread to give it a more indulgent twist.

This is one sandwich that will make your shop a popular location for customers who only want a light yet filling lunch option.

  1. Roast Beef and Cheddar Sandwich

This option will resonate with coffee shop customers who prefer something more substantial. Truth be told, this is one good option that will hit the ground running.

It features thinly sliced roast beef piled high on a Kaiser roll or ciabatta bread, finished up with sharp cheddar cheese, horseradish sauce, and arugula, to give it a unique flavor profile.

Make sure to include this sandwich in your menu to ensure that customers have a hearty option that aligns perfectly well with a strong, dark roast coffee.